NACSA Says American Enterprise Institute Report on Charter School Application Process Goes too Far, Calls for Focus on Balanced Authorizing Practices

NACSA Says American Enterprise Institute Report on Charter School Application Process Goes too Far, Calls for Focus on Balanced Authorizing Practices

Chicago, Ill. – The National Association of Charter School Authorizers (NACSA) released the following statement in response to the recommendations in a report on authorizer accountability released today by the American Enterprise Institute:

“The American Enterprise Institute’s report, ‘The Paperwork Pile-up: Measuring the Burden of Charter School Applications,’ identifies an important challenge facing the charter community, but if implemented, the report’s recommendations would go too far and would disrupt the critical balance between autonomy and accountability.

NACSA has helped our nation’s charter school authorizers improve how they do their jobs for over 15 years. We know that charter schools innovate and excel when they have autonomy and that the interests of students and taxpayers are protected when authorizers ask the right questions. That’s why the principles and standards we continue to hone include practices that both protect charter schools’ autonomy and that help protect the rights of students and the interests of taxpayers.

While we agree with the spirit of the paper, its recommendations would tilt current authorizing practices too far in the direction of autonomy and jeopardize students and taxpayers in the process. For example, it asserts that requests for a school to explain its discipline policy are “onerous and inappropriate,” as are requests to address student health services and safety. Requests for a school to present a two-year operational budget and a school calendar are also considered either onerous or inappropriate.

NACSA believes it is appropriate and completely reasonable to understand the operating budget of any organization that will receive millions of taxpayer dollars, including a charter school. Given recent concerns over equity related to school discipline, authorizers have every right to know a school’s intended discipline policy before granting public funds to open a school

Charter schools and authorizing are receiving increasing attention from interest groups of many persuasions. Some are calling for increased regulation of charter schools. Others, like AEI, are calling for less regulation. None of the groups calling for more and less regulation has the experience working with charter schools and authorizers that informs NACSA’s own Principles and Standards for Quality Charter School Authorizing. NACSA has conducted 60 in-depth, formative evaluations of authorizers’ practices and managed the evaluation of nearly 500 charter school proposals. We welcome the discussion about how to streamline the charter application process and agree that some authorizers’ application processes have become too lengthy and burdensome.

To enable the creation of new charter schools that serve students well, it is essential that we maintain the balance of autonomy and accountability. Too much or too little of one or the other jeopardizes all charter schools and, more importantly, jeopardizes the students those schools are intended to serve.

View Press Release PDF

Most Recent Posts
Applying Charter Authorizing Principles in the Early Childhood Field
This blog was written by Abby McCartney, Director, Early Care and Education, Afton Partners and Carrie Stewart, Co-Founder and Managing Partner, Afton Partners Introduction: Early Care and Education at a...
2023 State of Charter Authorizing Report
Authorizing is the most consequential public school governance reform of the past two decades. For the last 20+ years, authorizers have been creating a new landscape, where school autonomy—balanced by...
The Way to More Community-Responsive Schools
Authorizers don’t develop or design new schools. But they are the gateways that help bring these schools to life, providing the conditions and expectations for what extraordinary schools and equitable...