Authorizing by the Numbers

Authorizing by the Numbers

We spend plenty of time talking about the why and how of our work, as we seek to ensure more high-quality, innovative, and equitable educational opportunities for children. But every few years, it’s critical that we also talk about the who. Who is doing the work of charter school authorizing today, how is that changing, and why does that matter?

Today we release Authorizing by the Numbers, a comprehensive study of the numbers and types of authorizers, the size of their portfolios, and how authorizing has changed from 2016 to 2020. We invite you to explore this new data. Here are some key themes:

Fewer authorizers oversee more charter schools, and the data suggests that’s generally a good thing.

There were nearly 70 net fewer authorizers in 2020 compared to 2016, but remaining authorizers oversee a growing charter school sector. Authorizers exiting the profession oversaw few charter schools: 95% of authorizers exiting oversaw three or fewer schools, including more than threequarters that oversaw only one school. Exiting authorizers also seem to be confined to just a few multiauthorizer states, including places that implemented state policies designed to evaluate and strengthen authorizing, like Ohio and Minnesota. It’s also notable that there are some additional Independent Charter Board (ICB) and State Education Agency (SEA) authorizers, as they tend to have the requisite capacity and commitment to execute authorizing responsibilities welltwo important elements linked to strong student and public interest outcomesand have grown their portfolios of schools more rapidly than other authorizer types.

There is churn among school district authorizers.

The vast majority of institutions leaving and entering authorizing are school district authorizers overseeing few charter schools. It’s important that new authorizers have the requisite capacity, foundational practices, and longterm vision for authorizing, something state policy can help advance. While school districts remain the biggest group of authorizers, the data also shows that they do not oversee the majority of our nation’s charter schools: only 48% of all charters were overseen by districts in 2020, down from 52% in 2016.

As highquality charter schooling expands, innovative thinking about who authorizes could be key to expanding quality opportunities for students.

NACSA will continue to support policies that enable potential charter schools to have access to more than one quality authorizer within
a state, along with
policies and practices ensuring that multiple authorizers do not dilute quality. Now is an excellent timeas public education leaders work harder to listen and respond to the aspirations and needs of local communitiesto imagine new possibilities for
authorizing. Some worth exploring include Historically Black Colleges and Universities (
HBCUs), career and technical colleges and universities, and mayors offices. These, and other interesting ideas like specialized authorizing focused on new ways of organizing teaching and learning, not only can provide highquality, innovative, and equitable educational opportunities, but may also lead to a more diverse, thriving profession resulting in stronger student outcomes.

Over the coming months, we will explore these and other key themes more deeply to extract key learnings for authorizing, policymaking, and other school oversight approaches. Be on the lookout for additional data, perspectives, webinars, and more.

We’ll also discuss the impact of this research at our upcoming leadership conference, NACSACon 2022: Excellence from Communities. If you haven’t already registered, it isn’t too late! Come and be part of some fascinating and inspiring conversations as we build the future
of authorizing.

Most Recent Posts
NACSA names Guerschmide Saint-Ange as Chief Operating Officer
Karega Rausch, president and CEO of the National Association of Charter School Authorizers (NACSA), announced today that Guerschmide Saint-Ange will serve as NACSA’s chief operating officer (COO). Saint-Ange, formerly NACSA’s...
Are Authorizers Missing Opportunities to Approve Excellent Schools? 
When our educational landscape has a variety of public school options for families, every student can attend a school that meets their needs.   Authorizers have a significant impact on shaping...
How to Build an Inclusive Workforce Culture: Let the Data Drive You
FOURTH IN A SERIES In our rapidly evolving world, fostering diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) within organizations has become more than a moral imperative. It’s also a strategic necessity.  However,...